In a new interview with the “Musicians On Couches Drinking Coffee” podcast, legendary drummer Carmine Appice once again repeated the claim that one of John Bonham‘s licks, a triplet bass drum motif used most prominently on “Good Times, Bad Times”, the opening track on the first LED ZEPPELIN album, was inspired by something Carmine did on either the first VANILLA FUDGE LP or the “Renaissance” record.
Carmine said (as transcribed by BLABBERMOUTH.NET): “What it was I heard [LED ZEPPELIN‘s debut] album. [LED ZEPPELIN and VANILLA FUDGE] had the same attorney, and they were on the same label. And my manager was connected to their manager, Peter Grant; they were both heavyweights. So when that album came out — before it came out — they gave us a copy and they said, ‘We wanna put Jimmy Page‘s new band on with you guys.’ We knew Jimmy Page; we used to do gigs with THE YARDBIRDS. So when I heard the record and I heard the triplet on ‘Good Times, Bad Times’, I said, ‘Woah! What a foot on this guy. It’s pretty amazing.’ So on the very first gig that they played with us, I said to John, before the gig, I said, ‘I love your foot on the record. It’s unbelievable.’ And he said, ‘Thanks. I got that from you.’ I said, ‘You did. I don’t remember doing that.’ He said, ‘Yeah, it’s right on your VANILLA FUDGE record.’ I said, ‘Where is that?’ Because in those days — still today, I don’t play what I rehearse; I play whatever comes to me when I’m doing it. So I had done it somewhere on a record, so he pointed it out — I think it was on the ‘Renaissance’ record… And he said, ‘So I just got that concept from what you did and then did what I did.’ And I said, ‘Wow.'”
Appice went on to say that he didn’t feel comfortable bringing up his influence on Bonham in interviews for a long time due to the way the LED ZEPPELIN legend is credited with being an innovator who brought an unprecedented level of power, speed, and control to rock music, thereby setting the bar for all drummers coming after him.
“There was a time I couldn’t really talk about this because ZEPPELIN was so big and people envisioned John Bonham like he was ‘it,’ he was God, and you can’t talk about that he got something from you, ’cause he was God — God doesn’t get anything from anybody,” Carmine said. “And when I said it, people would say that I was crazy, I was egoing out, this and that. Then there was a book that came out called ‘[John Bonham:] A Thunder Of Drums’. When that came out, it told these stories and it told about when John Bonham came back from playing with VANILLA FUDGE, how gaga he was about meeting me. And he was hanging out with Cozy Powell, telling him the stories about hanging out with me. And they were both gaga about hanging out with me. I didn’t know anything about that until this book came out. After that book came out, it told, with that being said, that he actually did listen to me and that I was an influence on him.”
A 2017 blog post by Rain City Drummer, a blog dedicated to the art of drumming, attempted to get to the bottom of Appice‘s claim that Bonham lifted the lick from Carmine, apparently without any success.
Carmine previously said that Bonham took the bass drum triplets from the VANILLA FUDGE song “Ticket To Ride”, telling Classic Rock Revisited in a 2006 interview: “When I first heard John Bonham do that triplet thing on the bass drum, I went up to him and said, ‘John, that is amazing. I have to admit that I took that from you.’ He looked at me and said, ‘What are you talking about? I took that from you!’ I replied, ‘I don’t do that. You couldn’t have taken it from me.’ He proceeded to tell me where I did actually do that on the first VANILLA FUDGE record and he was right. I only did it for a moment on that album and he took it and made something bigger and better out of it.”
Back in 2014, Carmine said that he would love to play with a reunited LED ZEPPELIN, claiming that he is a better fit to replace Bonham than John‘s son Jason.
“Everybody in that band there is legendary… They’re old school and legendary. Jason isn’t legendary, and he’s not old school,” Appice explained to the “Totally Driven Radio” podcast. “He’s John Bonham‘s son, but he don’t play like John Bonham. He plays more… He plays like him. He’s not John. He’s got that name, but he’s not John Bonham. I’m not John Bonham either, but I think my style might be close, ’cause I came first, and John listened to stuff I did and did it his own way. And we took ’em on their first tour. It’s very close-sounding stuff in feel.”
In recent months, VANILLA FUDGE has released remastered versions of its covers of two LED ZEPPELIN classics, “Immigrant Song” and “Rock And Roll”, via Golden Robot Records. A third cover, “Ramble On”, will arrive on November 30. All three tracks come from the soon-to-be-released album “Vanilla Zeppelin”.
